The Why, Where and When

In May 2011 my daughter, Judith Prays, suggested that we do some Torah study together. It was an exciting proposition for me. Undeterred by ...

42. B'midbar - Tribes (Matot)

n which Moses describes the laws of oaths. The Israelites battle the Midianites. The tribes of Reuven and Gad request to dwell outside of the Land of Israel..


The rules of Vows to G-d:If a person takes a vow before G-d that vow is binding, unless the person is a virgin then her father can relieve her of her vow, or a married woman  then her husband can relieve her of her vow (do not judge).
Revenge against the Midianites: Moses tells the Israelites to send 1000 men from each tribe to take revenge on the Midianites for trying to seduce the Israelites into idolatry. The army of 12000 lead by Pinchas mounts a surprise attack and kills all the Midianite males, including all the kings and the prophet Balaam.
Women, beasts and possessions, that were not burnt, were taken as spoils (do not judge). Moses orders every woman and male child killed and only virgin girls kept as spoils (do not judge).
Purification after battle and division of spoils with allotting a part for G-d: The soldiers must purify themselves and their belongings after contact with corpses then all the spoils must be counted and fairly divided between the soldiers, the community, and G-d. It turns out that not a single warrior was lost in the battle and an additional gift of gold is offered to G-d.
Fair Participation in Battle:The cattle-breeding tribes of Reuven and Gad ask permission to settle east of the Jordan where the pastures are good. Moses is outraged, thinking that Reuven and Gad are acting like the skeptical spies, afraid of battle. But when Reuven and Gad persuade Moses that they will leave their families and cattle behind and go to battle, Moses agrees, on condition that if they go back on their promise to fight, they forfeit the claim to the land.
 Nina’s Comment:
It is hard for a modern reader to swallow the text about a woman having no will of her own, until she is a widow. Even harder to see all-out extermination of a people with only virgin girls spared to be used as the winner’s loot. But this is where the people were then. G-d takes them as they are and elevates them - see Masei.